Skip to main content

Flyers fans have every right to question Rick Tocchet's future

Flyers fans have taken matters into their own hands by putting up a "fire Tocchet" billboard and plane banner
ByChris Fischer
Oct 27, 2026; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Philadelphia Flyers head coach Rick Tocchet behind the bench against the Columbus Blue Jackets during the third period at Xfinity Mobile Arena. Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-Imagn Images
Oct 27, 2026; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Philadelphia Flyers head coach Rick Tocchet behind the bench against the Columbus Blue Jackets during the third period at Xfinity Mobile Arena. Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Flyers fans have done a complete 180 on the club's bench boss Rick Tocchet since the end of last season. Philadelphia massively overachieved in the 2025-2026 season. They were expected to be a bottom feeder, and Tocchet led them to a second-round playoff appearance.

In Tocchet's first season, the club went 43-27-12, eliminated the rival Penguins, and then got swept by the eventual Stanley Cup Champion Carolina Hurricanes.

Entering the 2026 season, much of the Flyers fanbase expected another season of playoff hockey, but this iteration of the team has been the complete opposite.

After a first-season coach bump, the Flyers have regressed right back to being a bottom team in the NHL, and fans are right to question Tocchet's job security moving forward.

Tocchet's style ruins young skilled players

Rick Tocchet's style of coaching is not conducive to the growth of highly skilled young offensive talents. Prioritizing a defence-first and hard-nosed approach directly stunts the growth of the very players the club is building around.

Tocchet faced a ton of criticism for his time in Vancouver for how he managed and developed young players. Many people point to him as to why Elias Pettersson went from a star 1C to just a solid player. Vasily Podkolzin also struggled to earn Tocchet's trust but has broken out offensively since moving away from him.

In his first season coaching Philadelphia, Tocchet clashed with Michkov many times. The Flyers coach said disparaging things about Michkov to the media throughout the season. He benched him in key moments. Ultimately, his treatment of Michkov is a large reason for the Flyers franchise cornerstone's trade request.

Tocchet never really deserved the job in the first place

The Flyers are doing a similar thing the Canucks did under Tocchet. His first full season as the bench boss, Vancouver blew through expectations, finishing the season with 50 wins and earning 109 points. The Canucks suffered a Game 7 loss to the Oilers in the second round.

Following the Canucks' disappointing end to their impressive season, many expected the Canucks to be perennial contenders. JT Miller was a 103-point scorer, Quinn Hughes totalled 92 points, Elias Pettersson had 89 himself, and Thatcher Demko was a Vezina runner-up.

The Canucks seemingly had all the pieces in place, a 1C, an elite 2C, one of the best 1D in hockey, and a Vezina caliber goalie to go along with a Jack Adams winner. Despite that, the club missed the playoffs entirely the following season. Pettersson and Miller took huge regressions, and locker room turmoil resulted in Miller getting traded, the team falling apart, and forcing the team to tear it down to the studs.

This poses the question: why was he even hired? Tocchet coached for nine seasons prior to Philadelphia and only made the playoffs twice. His coaching style does not favor young rebuilding teams, so that argument goes out the window as well. Aside from one successful regular season in Vancouver, which was followed by a massive regression, Tocchet has never been an elite coach.

The team is struggling

The fact that the Flyers are struggling mightily is the least surprising part of this whole Tocchet saga. Aside from a two-month stretch that thrust the team into the playoffs last season, the Flyers have never shown that they are truly an elite team.

The rebuild is far from over. The Flyers have no semblance of a plan to acquire a number one center and defenseman. Their failed pursuit of Leo Carlsson was the closest they have been to a true 1C. The decision to match for the Ducks was inevitable and the obvious move, yet somehow that's the closest the Flyers have been to a 1C.

No team is winning a Stanley Cup with players the caliber of Trevor Zegras and Travis Sanheim as their 1C and 1D. Those players are very good, but not enough to be your best players. The truth of the matter is the team just is not good enough right now.

The roster is mainly unchanged, with depth forwards and a backup goalie being the only additions, yet the team is 5th-worst in points percentage. At 6-11-6, the Flyers are looking wildly incompetent over a quarter of the way into the season.

They need to sell off pieces and continue the rebuild in the hopes of acquiring the key pieces they need for the future. Rick Tocchet is not the coach that should be leading the club during a rebuild, and Flyers fans are hoping for the firing of Tocchet immediately.

Add us as a preferred source on Google